Tory, a successful publishing executive, decides to adopt a baby girl after her search for a man to fill the paternal void in her life proves fruitless. Despite having a checklist of ideal qualities, she abandons the dating scene to focus on her new role as a mother while striving to establish herself as CEO and secure a promising new children’s author. In response, the Love Club steps in to assist Tory by hiring Finn as a nanny. However, when it is revealed that Finn was never actually a nanny, the Love Club must persuade Tory that, despite his lack of formal qualifications, Finn might be the children’s author and partner she has been seeking.