When up-and-coming filmmaker David is ordered by a judge to participate in a community service program at the Jewish Community Center, he is convinced that he doesn’t fit in. However, when he is paired with the lively Sarah for a trip to the Brooklyn Bridge, unexpected chemistry develops, challenging his beliefs. As their relationship begins to blossom, they must navigate Sarah’s previous romantic entanglements, David’s critical mother, and their own preconceived notions of what love should be.