Hannah relocates to live with Aaron, a captivating Amish leader, to assist in caring for his sick wife. Having departed from her own Amish community, Hannah appreciates the hospitality and employment offered by Aaron and his wife. However, as she goes about her daily tasks, an undeniable attraction develops between her and Aaron. Aware that their clandestine affair is morally wrong, Hannah chooses to break it off. But when Aaron’s wife unexpectedly passes away under suspicious circumstances, Hannah is accused of murder and must battle to clear her name.