Every December, the quaint town of Ponchatoula, Louisiana, upholds a cherished Christmas tradition by placing a wooden wishing box in the park. One evening, after spending time together, Maddie urges her sister Faith to make a wish for her first experience of true love. The following day, both sisters are taken aback when Faith encounters the charming and eligible Andrew. As Christmas approaches, Faith starts to question whether Andrew is truly her ideal match or if her wish is actually guiding her towards her best friend, Wyatt.