A television reality team comes to town to capture the life of a secluded Amish group known as the Swartzentruber Amish. However, their project takes a different turn when an Amish witch named Brauchau dies, halting their filming. Following her funeral, the townsfolk urge the crew to investigate the supernatural occurrences that have started to trouble them. To succeed, the production team and the residents must confront the malevolent forces determined to annihilate them.