The Amityville myth continues as a tenant in a nearby boarding house passes away under puzzling conditions. Her closest companions, Brigitta and Bermuda, along with Bermuda’s sister Sentinel and the boarding house proprietor, Ms. Ernie, are left heartbroken. The situation worsens with the entrance of Hank Denton, an odd and brash detective who is perpetually dressed in cowboy attire. As suspicions arise among the girls that their friend Margaret might still be alive, tensions escalate. Meanwhile, the detective’s erratic conduct intensifies, and it seems the house itself might be turning against its inhabitants.